Methodology — autodefect.org
AUTODEFECT.ORG BMW HVAC EVAPORATOR REGISTRY · INDEPENDENT REPORT A FAILURE
Redacted repair invoice being reviewed before upload to the Registry
RESEARCH · METHODOLOGY

The method matters more than the volume

The Registry exists to determine whether documented owner records demonstrate a recurring pattern of premature HVAC evaporator failure. Every submission is read by a person, graded against its documentation, redacted, and only then published. Nothing publishes automatically, and no entry is labeled an evaporator failure on symptoms alone.

Independent consumer evidence registry. Not affiliated with, sponsored by, authorized by, operated by, or endorsed by BMW AG, BMW of North America, LLC, or any BMW dealership.

EVIDENCE CLASSIFICATION

Each record carries exactly one status. The grade describes the strength of the documentation — not how serious the failure was, and not whether the owner is believed. Levels are never combined in public totals without labeling.

{{ l.tag }} {{ l.name }}

{{ l.def }}

CLASSIFICATION PRINCIPLES

SYMPTOMS ARE NOT A DIAGNOSIS

Driver-side-cold / passenger-side-warm airflow is a common evaporator symptom — and also a symptom of condenser leaks, compressor faults, service-port leaks, line leaks, and blend-door failures. An entry is classified by what the diagnostic paperwork shows, never by vent temperatures alone.

ALL OUTCOMES ARE RECORDED

The Registry collects warranty-paid, goodwill-paid, and owner-paid results alike, including cases resolved entirely by BMW. A registry that only recorded bad outcomes could not demonstrate a pattern — or its absence.

NEUTRAL LANGUAGE

Records state what documents show, in their own terms. A pending goodwill review is reported as pending — never as a denial. The Registry's strongest permissible claim: verified submissions raise questions about whether premature HVAC evaporator failures may recur within certain models or production periods. It has not established a manufacturer-wide failure rate or common engineering cause.

HVAC, NOT EMISSIONS "EVAP"

This Registry concerns the air-conditioning (HVAC) evaporator core behind the dashboard — not the emissions-system "EVAP" component. Where a source document says "EVAP," the Registry records the exact wording and which system was actually meant.

WHAT A SUBMISSION COLLECTS

The 14-step intake collects five groups of facts, so a complete case arrives structured rather than as a free-text complaint.

{{ g.n }} {{ g.name }} {{ g.what }}

VERIFICATION & ABUSE CONTROLS

A public registry is only as credible as its resistance to junk data. Before anything reaches the public table:

{{ c }}
Macro of a dashboard climate vent

Questions about a record?

Anyone — including BMW, a dealership, or a facility named in a record — can report an inaccuracy or submit a right-of-reply response. Corrections are reviewed against the underlying documents, and materially changed records keep a visible version history.

REPORT AN INACCURACY